Best Melodica (2026): 5 Picks Compared
Updated Oct 24, 2026 · By 
Jonah Mercer · Ranked from listed specifications · How we rank
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Buying through the Amazon links on this page costs you nothing extra. Full disclosure
For the search best melodica, the Eastar 32-key melodica leads as Best Overall: 32 keys, a case, a shoulder strap and a 6-month warranty at 0.8 lb. If you want 37 keys, the EastRock 37-key melodica is the Runner-Up, with a hard bag and a 6-month warranty.
The picks at a glance
Which one should you buy?
- Beginners who want 32 keys with a case included: Eastar 32-Key Melodica Beginners Air Piano Keyboard See pick 1More picks: Best Beginner Melodica
- Advanced players who want 37 keys and a hard bag: EastRock 37 Key Black Melodica Keyboard Soprano See pick 2More picks: Best 37 Key Melodica
- Beginners who want 32 keys and a hard bag: EastRock 32 Key Black Melodica Keyboard Soprano See pick 3More picks: Best 32 Key Melodica
- Players who want 37 keys with a case included: Yamaha P-37D 37-key Pianica See pick 4
- Players who want 32 keys in pink: YAMAHA PIANICA 32keys See pick 5
Narrow it down
- Best Melodica Under $100
- Best Small Melodica
- Best Professional Melodica
- Best Melodica for Home
- Best Portable Melodica
- Best Mini Melodica
- Best Beginner Melodica
- Best 32 Key Melodica
- Best 37 Key Melodica
- Best Melodica for Professionals
The 5 picks, ranked
1Best Overall
Eastar 32-Key Melodica Beginners Air Piano Keyboard
- Keys: 32
- Case or gig bag included
- Mouthpiece included not stated in the listing
- 6 month warranty stated
- 0.8 lb, the lightest here
It earns Best Overall with 32 keys, a case, a shoulder strap and a 6-month warranty at 0.8 lb.
Who it suits
- Beginners who want 32 keys with a case included
- Players who want a shoulder strap in the box
Skip it if
- You want more than 32 keys
- You want a warranty longer than 6 months
The box holds the melodica, a tube, a shoulder strap and a bag. It has 32 keys, a phosphor bronze reed and a copper base, with a body of ABS resin. It weighs 0.8 lb, comes in black and carries a 6-month warranty.
2Runner-Up
EastRock 37 Key Black Melodica Keyboard Soprano
- Keys: 37
- Case or gig bag included
- Mouthpiece included
- 6-month warranty stated
It earns Runner-Up with 37 keys, phosphor bronze reeds and a hard bag with a shoulder strap.
Who it suits
- Advanced players who want 37 keys and a hard bag
- Beginners who want mouthpieces and a cleaning cloth included
Skip it if
- You want fewer than 37 keys
- You want a melodica lighter than 1.1 lb
The package holds the melodica, mouthpieces, an extension hose, a cleaning cloth, a shoulder strap and a hard bag. It has 37 keys, phosphor bronze reeds and a copper base, with a body of food-grade ABS resin. It weighs 1.1 lb, comes in black and carries a 6-month warranty.
3Also Great
EastRock 32 Key Black Melodica Keyboard Soprano
- Keys: 32
- Case or gig bag included
- Mouthpiece included
- 6-month warranty stated
It holds Also Great with 32 keys, phosphor bronze reeds and a hard bag with a shoulder strap.
Who it suits
- Beginners who want 32 keys and a hard bag
- Players who want mouthpieces and a cleaning cloth included
Skip it if
- You want more than 32 keys
- You want a melodica lighter than 2.4 lb
The package holds the melodica, mouthpieces, an extension hose, a cleaning cloth, a shoulder strap and a hard bag. It has 32 keys, phosphor bronze reeds and a copper base, with a body of food-grade ABS resin. It weighs 2.4 lb, comes in black and carries a 6-month warranty.
4Also Great
Yamaha P-37D 37-key Pianica
- Keys: 37
- Case or gig bag included
- Mouthpiece included not stated in the listing
- 2-year warranty stated
It holds Also Great with 37 keys, a case and a 2-year warranty.
Who it suits
- Players who want 37 keys with a case included
- Buyers who want a 2-year warranty
Skip it if
- You want fewer than 37 keys
- You want a warranty longer than 2 years
It is a 37-key pianica with a case and a polished brown finish. It weighs 1.7 lb, carries a 2-year warranty, and the model number is P-37D.
5Also Great
YAMAHA PIANICA 32keys
- Keys: 32
- Case or gig bag included not stated in the listing
- Mouthpiece included not stated in the listing
It holds Also Great with 32 keys in pink at 1.3 lb.
Who it suits
- Players who want 32 keys in pink
- Players who want a 32-key pianica at 1.3 lb
Skip it if
- You want more than 32 keys
- You want a melodica lighter than 1.3 lb
It is a 32-key pianica in pink, with alloy steel and metal materials and a plastic body. It weighs 1.3 lb, and the model number is P-32EP.
Side by side
| Product | Keys | Case or gig bag included | Mouthpiece included | Weight | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Eastar 32-Key Melodica Beginners Air Piano Keyboard | 32 | Yes | Not stated | 0.8 lb | 6 month |
| EastRock 37 Key Black Melodica Keyboard Soprano | 37 | Yes | Yes | 1.1 lb | 6-month |
| EastRock 32 Key Black Melodica Keyboard Soprano | 32 | Yes | Yes | 2.4 lb | 6-month |
| Yamaha P-37D 37-key Pianica | 37 | Yes | Not stated | 1.7 lb | 2-year |
| YAMAHA PIANICA 32keys | 32 | Not stated | Not stated | 1.3 lb | Not stated |
How we ranked these melodicas
Every pick has at least 100 customer ratings on Amazon and a listing with real specifications. The order mixes two things: how each model compares on the specs below (higher share of the best value in this group scores more), and how widely it is bought. The spec score runs from 9.0 to 9.8 and only compares these picks with each other. A spec the listing does not state is left out and the other specs are re-weighted; a listing with fewer than 2 stated specs is scored at half. We do not test gear in person. Full method.
- Keys weight 2
- Case or gig bag included weight 1
- Mouthpiece included weight 1
Buying advice: melodica
Count the keys before you buy
Melodicas here come with 32 keys or 37 keys. The Eastar, the EastRock 32-key and the Yamaha P-32EP have 32 keys. The EastRock 37-key and the Yamaha P-37D have 37 keys. More keys cover a wider range of notes, so match the key count to the music you play.
Check the case and the carry strap
A case and a strap change how you carry the melodica. The Eastar comes with a bag and a shoulder strap. The EastRock 37-key and 32-key models come with a hard bag and a shoulder strap. The Yamaha P-37D comes with a case.
Weigh the warranty and the weight
Warranty terms differ across this list. The Eastar, the EastRock 37-key and the EastRock 32-key carry a 6-month warranty. The Yamaha P-37D carries a 2-year warranty. Weights run from 0.8 lb to 2.4 lb here, so check the weight if you carry the melodica far.
Frequently asked questions
How many keys do I need on a melodica?
This list has 32-key and 37-key models. The Eastar, the EastRock 32-key and the Yamaha P-32EP have 32 keys, and the EastRock 37-key and the Yamaha P-37D have 37 keys. Pick the count that covers the notes you play.
Do melodicas come with a case?
The Eastar comes with a bag, the EastRock models come with a hard bag, and the Yamaha P-37D comes with a case.
What reeds do these melodicas use?
The Eastar, the EastRock 37-key and the EastRock 32-key use phosphor bronze reeds. The Yamaha P-37D material is brass, and the Yamaha P-32EP materials are alloy steel and metal.
How much do these melodicas weigh?
The Eastar weighs 0.8 lb, the EastRock 37-key weighs 1.1 lb, the Yamaha P-32EP weighs 1.3 lb, the Yamaha P-37D weighs 1.7 lb, and the EastRock 32-key weighs 2.4 lb.
Gear that goes with it
Best Keyboard PianosTop pick: Casio Casiotone CT-S200RD
Best MIDI KeyboardTop pick: M-AUDIO Keystation 49 MK3 USB MIDI Controller
Best Digital PianoTop pick: GLARRY 88-Key Semi-Weighted Digital Piano
Best Piano StandTop pick: tipatyard Keyboard Stand & Bench SetMore melodicas guides
Specifications and availability come from each Amazon listing on Oct 24, 2026 and can change. Check the listing before you buy.